TheLucidSTEM · Chemistry olympiad feeder round mock · 120 minutes · 60 marks · Calculator allowed
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ · MARK SCHEME
Data sheet
Relative atomic masses: H 1.008, C 12.01, N 14.01, O 16.00, Al 26.98, S 32.06, Cl 35.45, K 39.10, Mn 54.94, Fe 55.85, Zn 65.38, Br 79.90, I 126.90, Pb 207.2
Constants: Faraday constant $F = 96\,485$ C mol-1; gas constant $R = 8.314$ J K-1 mol-1; molar volume of a gas at room temperature and pressure (RTP) $= 24.0$ dm3 mol-1; $0\ ^\circ\mathrm{C} = 273.15$ K; $1$ kW h $= 3.60\times10^{6}$ J.
Useful relations: $Q = It$; energy $= QV$; $\Delta H = \Delta U + \Delta n_{\mathrm{gas}}RT$; Beer-Lambert law $A = \varepsilon c l$; degree of unsaturation of CaHb $= (2a + 2 - b)/2$.
Structured questions
About 24 minutes per question. Marks for each part are shown in brackets.
1Smelting aluminium[12 marks]
Aluminium is made by electrolysing aluminium oxide dissolved in molten cryolite at about 960 °C. The cathode is the carbon lining of the cell, where aluminium metal collects. The anodes are large blocks of carbon, which are slowly used up because the oxide ions discharged there react with the carbon to give carbon dioxide.
A modern cell runs at a current of 300 kA and a voltage of 4.20 V. Its current efficiency is 94.0%: only 94.0% of the charge passed ends up as aluminium metal; the rest is wasted in side reactions.
(a) Write half-equations for the reactions at the cathode and at the anode.
Answer: Cathode $\mathrm{Al^{3+} + 3e^- \rightarrow Al}$; anode $\mathrm{C + 2O^{2-} \rightarrow CO_2 + 4e^-}$
Cathode: $\mathrm{Al^{3+} + 3e^- \rightarrow Al}$ [1].
Anode: $\mathrm{C + 2O^{2-} \rightarrow CO_2 + 4e^-}$ [1]. Also accept $\mathrm{2O^{2-} \rightarrow O_2 + 4e^-}$ followed by $\mathrm{C + O_2 \rightarrow CO_2}$. Electrons on the wrong side lose the mark.
(b) Calculate the charge, in coulombs, that must be used to make 1.000 tonne (1000 kg) of aluminium.
Answer: $1.07\times10^{10}$ C
$n(\mathrm{Al}) = 1.000\times10^{6}/26.98 = 3.706\times10^{4}$ mol [1].
$Q = 3nF = 3\times3.706\times10^{4}\times96\,485 = 1.073\times10^{10}$ C [1].
Forgetting the factor 3 ($3.58\times10^{9}$ C) loses the second mark.
(c) Calculate how long, in hours, one cell takes to make 1.000 tonne of aluminium.
Answer: 10.6 h
Useful current $= 0.940\times3.00\times10^{5} = 2.82\times10^{5}$ A [1].
$t = 1.073\times10^{10}/2.82\times10^{5} = 3.80\times10^{4}$ s $= 10.6$ h [1].
Ignoring the efficiency gives 9.93 h and loses the first mark. Allow error carried forward from (b).
(d) Calculate the electrical energy used per tonne of aluminium. Give your answer in kilowatt hours (1 kW h $= 3.60\times10^{6}$ J).
Answer: $1.33\times10^{4}$ kW h (13.3 MW h)
Total charge passed $= 1.073\times10^{10}/0.940 = 1.141\times10^{10}$ C, so energy $= QV = 1.141\times10^{10}\times4.20 = 4.79\times10^{10}$ J [1].
$4.79\times10^{10}/3.60\times10^{6} = 1.33\times10^{4}$ kW h [1].
Using the charge from (b) without dividing by 0.940 gives $1.25\times10^{4}$ kW h and loses the first mark. Also accept $Pt$: $3.00\times10^{5}\times4.20\times3.80\times10^{4}$ s.
(e) Assume that all the charge that makes aluminium also oxidises carbon to carbon dioxide at the anode. Calculate the mass of carbon used up, and the volume of carbon dioxide formed at RTP, per tonne of aluminium.
Answer: 334 kg of carbon; 667 m3 of CO2
4 mol of electrons per mol of C, so $n(\mathrm{C}) = 3\times3.706\times10^{4}/4 = 2.780\times10^{4}$ mol, mass $= 2.780\times10^{4}\times12.01 = 3.34\times10^{5}$ g $= 334$ kg [1].
$V(\mathrm{CO_2}) = 2.780\times10^{4}\times24.0 = 6.67\times10^{5}$ dm3 $= 667$ m3 [1].
Equivalently: 3 mol of C for every 4 mol of Al, from $\mathrm{2Al_2O_3 + 3C \rightarrow 4Al + 3CO_2}$.
(f) In practice about 420 kg of anode carbon is used per tonne of aluminium. Suggest two reasons why this is more than your answer to (e).
Answer: Hot anodes also burn in air; some carbon monoxide is formed instead of CO2 (also: the wasted charge oxidises carbon; anode stubs are discarded)
Any two, [1] each:
- the hot carbon anodes react with oxygen of the air above the bath (they burn);
- some CO forms instead of CO2, which uses two carbon atoms for every four electrons instead of one;
- the 6% of wasted charge also oxidises carbon (for example aluminium dissolved in the melt is reoxidised by CO2, and the charge has to be passed again);
- the ends (butts) of used anodes cannot be consumed and are thrown away or recycled.
\"Impurities\" alone scores 0.
2A heavy grey metal and its oxides[12 marks]
A soft, dense grey metal X forms a white chloride, XCl2, that contains 25.5% chlorine by mass.
- X dissolves in dilute nitric acid to give a colourless solution of salt A.
- Adding potassium iodide solution to a solution of A gives a bright yellow precipitate B.
- Heating solid A strongly gives a brown gas C, a colourless gas that relights a glowing splint, and a yellow solid oxide D.
- Heating D gently in air for a long time gives a bright red oxide E containing 9.33% oxygen by mass.
- Warming E with concentrated nitric acid gives a solution of A and a dark brown solid oxide F.
(a) Use the formula XCl2 to find the relative atomic mass of X, and identify X.
Answer: $A_r \approx 207$; X is lead, Pb
In XCl2, 70.90 g of Cl is 25.5% of the mass, so $M(\mathrm{XCl_2}) = 70.90/0.255 = 278$ g mol-1 [1].
$A_r(\mathrm{X}) = 278 - 70.9 = 207$, so X is lead [1].
(b) Identify A, B, C and D, and write the equation for the thermal decomposition of A.
Answer: A Pb(NO3)2, B PbI2, C NO2, D PbO; $\mathrm{2Pb(NO_3)_2 \rightarrow 2PbO + 4NO_2 + O_2}$
A lead(II) nitrate, Pb(NO3)2, and B lead(II) iodide, PbI2 [1].
C nitrogen dioxide, NO2, and D lead(II) oxide, PbO [1].
$\mathrm{2Pb(NO_3)_2 \rightarrow 2PbO + 4NO_2 + O_2}$ [1]. Allow error carried forward from a wrong X if the chemistry is consistent.
(c) Find the formula of E. Show that it can be described as a mixed oxide containing lead in two different oxidation states, and state the ratio of the two kinds of lead.
Answer: Pb3O4 $=$ 2PbO$\cdot$PbO2: two Pb(II) for each Pb(IV)
Pb $90.67/207.2 = 0.4376$, O $9.33/16.00 = 0.583$; ratio $1 : 1.333 = 3 : 4$, so Pb3O4 [1].
Average oxidation state $+8/3$ is not a whole number; it is 2PbO$\cdot$PbO2, with two Pb(+2) for every one Pb(+4) [1].
Check: Pb3O4 has $64.00/685.6 = 9.33\%$ O.
(d) Write the equation for the reaction of E with nitric acid, which forms A and F.
Answer: $\mathrm{Pb_3O_4 + 4HNO_3 \rightarrow 2Pb(NO_3)_2 + PbO_2 + 2H_2O}$
$\mathrm{Pb_3O_4 + 4HNO_3 \rightarrow 2Pb(NO_3)_2 + PbO_2 + 2H_2O}$ [1]. F is lead(IV) oxide, PbO2. The acid reacts only with the basic PbO part; this is an acid-base reaction, not a redox one.
(e) F reacts with concentrated hydrochloric acid to give a white solid and a green gas. Write the equation. Explain why lead(IV) compounds are strong oxidising agents, while carbon(IV) and silicon(IV) compounds such as CO2 and SiO2 are not.
Answer: $\mathrm{PbO_2 + 4HCl \rightarrow PbCl_2 + Cl_2 + 2H_2O}$; down group 14 the +2 state becomes more stable than +4 (inert pair effect)
$\mathrm{PbO_2 + 4HCl \rightarrow PbCl_2 + Cl_2 + 2H_2O}$ [1].
Down group 14 the two outer s electrons (6s2 for lead) are held more tightly and are less often used in bonding (the inert pair effect), so +2 is the more stable state for lead and Pb(IV) is easily reduced to Pb(II); for C and Si the +4 state is the stable one [1].
\"Lead is a metal\" alone scores 0.
(f) The solubility product of B is $9.8\times10^{-9}$ mol3 dm-9 at 298 K. Calculate the solubility of B in water in g dm-3.
Answer: 0.62 g dm-3
$K_{sp} = [\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}][\mathrm{I^-}]^2 = s(2s)^2 = 4s^3$, so $s = (9.8\times10^{-9}/4)^{1/3} = 1.35\times10^{-3}$ mol dm-3 [1].
$M(\mathrm{PbI_2}) = 461.0$ g mol-1, so solubility $= 1.35\times10^{-3}\times461.0 = 0.62$ g dm-3 [1].
Using $K_{sp} = s^3$ (gives $2.1\times10^{-3}$ mol dm-3, 0.99 g dm-3) or $s\cdot2s$ loses the first mark.
3Four aromatic isomers[12 marks]
Four hydrocarbons W, X, Y and Z are isomers. Each contains 90.5% carbon by mass and has relative molecular mass 106. None of them decolourises bromine water in the dark.
- Heating each with alkaline potassium manganate(VII), then acidifying, oxidises every carbon chain attached to a benzene ring to a COOH group. W gives an acid C7H6O2; X, Y and Z each give a different acid C8H6O4.
- When heated, only the acid from Y loses a molecule of water to form a cyclic anhydride.
- With bromine and an iron(III) bromide catalyst, Z gives only one monobromination product, C8H9Br.
(a) Show that the molecular formula of the hydrocarbons is C8H10.
Answer: Empirical formula C4H5 ($M = 53$); $106/53 = 2$, so C8H10
C $90.5/12.01 = 7.54$, H $9.5/1.008 = 9.42$; ratio $1 : 1.25 = 4 : 5$, empirical formula C4H5 [1].
$M(\mathrm{C_4H_5}) = 53.1$; $106/53.1 = 2$, so C8H10 [1].
(b) Calculate the degree of unsaturation (rings plus double bonds) of C8H10, and explain why it, together with the bromine water result, points to a benzene ring.
Answer: 4; a benzene ring (one ring and three C=C) that does not add bromine
$(2\times8 + 2 - 10)/2 = 4$; a benzene ring accounts for exactly 4 (one ring and three double bonds), and benzene rings do not decolourise bromine water, unlike alkenes [1]. Both the value and the reason are needed.
(c) Give the structures and names of W, X, Y and Z. Explain each choice briefly.
Answer: W ethylbenzene; X 1,3-dimethylbenzene; Y 1,2-dimethylbenzene; Z 1,4-dimethylbenzene
W gives benzoic acid, C6H5COOH, so it has one side chain of two carbons: ethylbenzene, C6H5CH2CH3 [1].
X, Y, Z give benzenedicarboxylic acids, so they are the three dimethylbenzenes. Only the 1,2-acid (COOH groups next to each other) can close a five-membered anhydride ring, so Y is 1,2-dimethylbenzene [1].
Z gives one ring monobromination product, so all four ring hydrogens are equivalent: Z is 1,4-dimethylbenzene, and X is 1,3-dimethylbenzene [1].
Old names (o-, m-, p-xylene) are accepted.
(d) How many different ring monobromination products, C8H9Br, can be formed from X and from Y?
Answer: X: 3; Y: 2
X (1,3-dimethylbenzene) has ring hydrogens at C2, C4/C6 (equivalent) and C5: 3 products [1].
Y (1,2-dimethylbenzene) has ring hydrogens at C3/C6 and C4/C5: 2 products [1].
Allow error carried forward from wrong structures in (c) if the counting is right for the structures given.
(e) Predict the 1H NMR spectrum of Z: the number of signals, the ratio of their areas, and the splitting of each signal.
Answer: 2 signals, ratio 3 : 2 (6H : 4H), both singlets
Two environments: the six CH3 hydrogens and the four ring hydrogens, area ratio $6 : 4 = 3 : 2$ [1].
Both signals are singlets: the CH3 hydrogens have no H on the neighbouring carbon, and the four ring hydrogens are all equivalent, so they do not split each other [1].
(f) In ultraviolet light, W reacts with bromine mainly at the CH2 group, not at the CH3 group or on the ring. Name the main product and explain why this position reacts. Will the product rotate the plane of polarised light? Explain.
Answer: (1-Bromoethyl)benzene; the benzylic radical is stabilised by the ring; chiral, but formed as a racemic mixture, so no rotation
(1-Bromoethyl)benzene, C6H5CHBrCH3; removing H from CH2 gives a radical next to the ring, which is stabilised by delocalisation of the unpaired electron into the ring [1].
The product is chiral, but the planar radical is attacked equally from both faces, so a racemic (50 : 50) mixture forms and there is no overall rotation [1].
\"Yes, it is chiral\" alone loses the second mark.
4Burning naphthalene in a bomb[12 marks]
Naphthalene, C10H8, is a white solid made of two fused benzene-like rings. Its enthalpy of combustion is measured in a bomb calorimeter: a sealed steel vessel full of oxygen, standing in a fixed mass of water. The reaction happens at constant volume, so the energy released is $-\Delta_c U$, not $-\Delta_c H$. All temperature rises below are already corrected for heat loss; ignore the energy from the ignition wire.
Calibration. 0.8155 g of benzoic acid, which releases 26.434 kJ per gram when burnt in a bomb, raises the temperature by 2.142 K.
Experiment. 0.6012 g of naphthalene, burnt in the same calorimeter with the same mass of water, raises the temperature by 2.402 K. Both runs take place close to 298 K.
Data (kJ mol-1, at 298 K):
| quantity | value |
|---|---|
| $\Delta_f H^\circ$ of CO2(g) | $-393.5$ |
| $\Delta_f H^\circ$ of H2O(l) | $-285.8$ |
| enthalpy of sublimation of naphthalene | $+72.6$ |
| enthalpy of atomisation of C(s, graphite) | $+717$ |
| mean bond enthalpies: H-H, C-C, C=C, C-H | 436, 347, 612, 413 |
(a) Calculate the heat capacity of the calorimeter (vessel plus water), in kJ K-1.
Answer: $C = 10.06$ kJ K-1
Energy released by the benzoic acid $= 0.8155\times26.434 = 21.56$ kJ [1].
$C = 21.56/2.142 = 10.06$ kJ K-1 [1].
Using $mc\Delta T$ with $c = 4.18$ J g-1 K-1 cannot work: the mass of water is not given, and the steel vessel also absorbs energy. That is the point of calibrating.
(b) Calculate the internal energy change of combustion, $\Delta_c U$, of naphthalene in kJ mol-1.
Answer: $\Delta_c U = -5151$ kJ mol-1
Energy released $= 10.06\times2.402 = 24.16$ kJ and $n = 0.6012/128.16 = 4.691\times10^{-3}$ mol [1].
$\Delta_c U = -24.16/4.691\times10^{-3} = -5151$ kJ mol-1, with the negative sign [1]. Accept $-5149$ to $-5155$ (the unrounded heat capacity gives $-5153$). Allow error carried forward from (a).
A positive value loses the second mark: the reaction releases energy.
(c) Write the equation for the complete combustion of solid naphthalene, giving liquid water. Hence calculate $\Delta_c H$ at 298 K.
Answer: $\mathrm{C_{10}H_8(s) + 12O_2(g) \rightarrow 10CO_2(g) + 4H_2O(l)}$; $\Delta_c H = -5156$ kJ mol-1
$\mathrm{C_{10}H_8(s) + 12O_2(g) \rightarrow 10CO_2(g) + 4H_2O(l)}$, so $\Delta n_{\mathrm{gas}} = 10 - 12 = -2$ [1].
$\Delta_c H = \Delta_c U + \Delta n_{\mathrm{gas}}RT = -5151 + (-2)(8.314\times10^{-3})(298) = -5151 - 5.0 = -5156$ kJ mol-1 [1]. Accept $-5154$ to $-5160$, or error carried forward from (b).
Common errors: counting the water as gas ($\Delta n_{\mathrm{gas}} = +2$, giving $-5146$), or using $R = 8.314$ without changing J to kJ.
(d) Use Hess's law to calculate the standard enthalpy change of formation of naphthalene, first as the solid and then as the gas.
Answer: $\Delta_f H^\circ$(s) $= +78$ kJ mol-1; $\Delta_f H^\circ$(g) $= +151$ kJ mol-1
$\Delta_f H^\circ(\mathrm{s}) = 10(-393.5) + 4(-285.8) - (-5156) = -5078.2 + 5156 = +78$ kJ mol-1 [1]. Accept $+74$ to $+82$, or error carried forward from (c): it is a small difference of two large numbers.
$\Delta_f H^\circ(\mathrm{g}) = 78 + 72.6 = +151$ kJ mol-1 [1].
Getting the sign of the combustion term wrong (giving about $-10\,234$) loses the first mark.
(e) One Kekulé structure of naphthalene has alternating single and double bonds between the carbon atoms. Count the C-C, C=C and C-H bonds in it, use the bond enthalpy data to estimate $\Delta_f H$ of gaseous naphthalene for that structure, and hence find the stabilisation (delocalisation) energy of naphthalene.
Answer: 5 C=C, 6 C-C, 8 C-H; estimate $+468$ kJ mol-1; stabilisation about 317 kJ mol-1
5 C=C, 6 C-C and 8 C-H bonds (11 carbon-carbon bonds in all) [1].
Atomising the elements: $10(717) + 4(436) = 8914$ kJ; forming the bonds releases $5(612) + 6(347) + 8(413) = 8446$ kJ; estimate $\Delta_f H(\mathrm{g}) = 8914 - 8446 = +468$ kJ mol-1 [1].
Stabilisation energy $= 468 - 151 = 317$ kJ mol-1: real naphthalene is this much more stable than the Kekulé structure [1]. Accept 310 to 325, or error carried forward from (d).
Common errors: comparing with the solid (giving about 390), although bond enthalpies only apply to gases; breaking 8 H-H bonds instead of 4 (the 8 H atoms come from 4 H2).
(f) The same method gives a stabilisation energy of 172 kJ mol-1 for benzene. Is naphthalene more or less stabilised per ring than benzene? Use this to explain why naphthalene reacts more readily than benzene.
Answer: Less per ring (317 < 2 x 172 = 344), so less stabilisation is lost when it reacts
$317 \lt 2\times172 = 344$ kJ mol-1, so naphthalene is less stabilised per ring; attacking one ring still leaves a complete benzene ring behind, so less delocalisation energy is lost and reaction is easier [1]. Both the comparison and the reason are needed for the mark.
5How much iron is in an iron tablet?[12 marks]
Iron tablets contain iron(II) sulfate. The label says that each tablet contains 65.0 mg of iron. On standing, some of the iron(II) may be oxidised by air to iron(III).
Five tablets are dissolved in dilute sulfuric acid and the solution is made up to 250.0 cm3.
- Titration 1. 25.00 cm3 of the solution is titrated with 0.00500 mol dm-3 potassium manganate(VII). Mean titre 20.80 cm3.
- Titration 2. Another 25.00 cm3 is shaken with excess zinc powder, which reduces all the iron(III) to iron(II). The zinc is filtered off, and the filtrate is titrated with the same manganate(VII). Mean titre 22.60 cm3.
(a) Write half-equations for the oxidation of Fe2+ and the reduction of MnO4- in acid, and the overall ionic equation.
Answer: $\mathrm{MnO_4^- + 5Fe^{2+} + 8H^+ \rightarrow Mn^{2+} + 5Fe^{3+} + 4H_2O}$
$\mathrm{Fe^{2+} \rightarrow Fe^{3+} + e^-}$ and $\mathrm{MnO_4^- + 8H^+ + 5e^- \rightarrow Mn^{2+} + 4H_2O}$ [1].
$\mathrm{MnO_4^- + 5Fe^{2+} + 8H^+ \rightarrow Mn^{2+} + 5Fe^{3+} + 4H_2O}$ [1].
(b) No indicator is added. State how the end point is seen.
Answer: First permanent pale pink colour
The manganate(VII) is decolourised while Fe2+ remains; the end point is the first permanent pale pink colour from one drop of excess MnO4- [1]. \"Turns purple\" is accepted only if \"pale pink\" or \"first permanent\" is also given.
(c) Explain why the tablets are dissolved in sulfuric acid and not in hydrochloric acid.
Answer: MnO4- would also oxidise Cl- to Cl2, so the titre would be too large
Manganate(VII) is a strong enough oxidising agent to oxidise chloride ions to chlorine, so extra manganate(VII) would be used and the titre would be too high [1].
(d) Use titration 2 to calculate the mass of iron in one tablet, and express it as a percentage of the value on the label.
Answer: 63.1 mg per tablet, 97.1% of the label value
$n(\mathrm{MnO_4^-}) = 22.60\times10^{-3}\times0.00500 = 1.130\times10^{-4}$ mol, so $n(\mathrm{Fe}) = 5.650\times10^{-4}$ mol in 25.00 cm3 [1].
In 250.0 cm3 (five tablets): $5.650\times10^{-3}$ mol; per tablet $1.130\times10^{-3}$ mol $\times55.85 = 63.1$ mg, which is $63.1/65.0 = 97.1\%$ of the label value [1].
Forgetting to divide by five tablets (316 mg) or to multiply by ten aliquots (6.31 mg) loses the second mark.
(e) Calculate the percentage of the iron that is still present as iron(II).
Answer: 92.0%
Titration 1 measures Fe2+ only; titration 2 measures Fe2+ plus the Fe3+ reduced by zinc, that is all the iron [1].
$\%\,\mathrm{Fe^{2+}} = 20.80/22.60\times100 = 92.0\%$ [1].
Giving 8.0% (the iron(III) fraction) loses the second mark unless the iron(II) value is also stated.
(f) Write the equation for the reaction of zinc with iron(III) ions. Explain why the zinc must be filtered off before titration 2.
Answer: $\mathrm{Zn + 2Fe^{3+} \rightarrow Zn^{2+} + 2Fe^{2+}}$; leftover zinc would reduce MnO4- (or keep re-forming Fe2+), making the titre too high
$\mathrm{Zn + 2Fe^{3+} \rightarrow Zn^{2+} + 2Fe^{2+}}$ [1].
Excess zinc would itself react with the manganate(VII) (directly, or by reducing the Fe3+ formed back to Fe2+), so the titre would be too large and there would be no sharp end point [1].
Note that Zn2+ left in solution does not react with manganate(VII).
(g) The iron(III) can also be measured by colorimetry. 1.00 cm3 of the tablet solution is diluted to 50.0 cm3 with excess potassium thiocyanate, which turns all the Fe3+ into the red complex [Fe(SCN)(H2O)5]2+. Its molar absorption coefficient is $7.0\times10^{3}$ dm3 mol-1 cm-1. Predict the absorbance in a 1.00 cm cell, using your results from the titrations.
Answer: $A \approx 0.25$
$n(\mathrm{Fe^{3+}})$ in 25.00 cm3 $= (22.60 - 20.80)\times10^{-3}\times0.00500\times5 = 4.50\times10^{-5}$ mol, so $[\mathrm{Fe^{3+}}] = 1.80\times10^{-3}$ mol dm-3 in the tablet solution [1].
After dilution by 50: $3.60\times10^{-5}$ mol dm-3, so $A = \varepsilon cl = 7.0\times10^{3}\times3.60\times10^{-5}\times1.00 = 0.25$ [1].
Forgetting the dilution ($A = 12.6$) loses the second mark; allow error carried forward from (e).
TheLucidSTEM practice paper. Questions are original and written in the style of a first national round; this is not an official olympiad paper.